IETF-SSH archive

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index][Old Index]

Re: DISCUSS comments on publickeyfile-09



Section 3, second paragraph, and elsewhere: "MUST NOT be longer than 72
bytes".  "bytes" is an imprecise term.  Do they really mean "8-bit ASCII
characters", octets, or are 9-bit bytes as implemented on older hardware
architectures also acceptable?

Section 3.4 uses the term "characters" to describe a line length
limitation.
Consistency would be good.

I agree that consistency would be good.

We do specify that that header-values MUST be encoded
in UTF8.  So changing to allow 72 characters could
mean a significant growth in the number of bytes allowed
on a line (*3 for Japanese text, for example.)

8-bit ASCII characters is close, except for those
UTF-8 header values.

What if we specified "MUST NOT be longer than 72 8-bit
bytes?"

Thanks,

Joseph





Home | Main Index | Thread Index | Old Index