Subject: Re: Packaged for NetBSD (Was: Why are there two 4.4BSD dev. groups)
To: David Brownlee <D.K.Brownlee@city.ac.uk>
From: Tim Walls <tjw1@doc.ic.ac.uk>
List: current-users
Date: 01/09/1995 10:28:08
> perception of NetBSD. Other obvious additions might be perl,
> top, screen, and a simple mail front end like pine.
> Would it be possible for someone in the core team to comment as to
> why this is a bad idea (to shut me up :), or if its likely to
> happen?
I am far from being in the core team :*), but I'll just say why I think
it might not be desirable (for me...):
o The distribution archives are already pretty large, and the installation
quite daunting as it stands. I think rather than having things like
perl etc. included in the distribution, a central binary/source archive
would be more helpful.
o A newly installed distribution takes some setting up as it stands, and
a lot of the people trying will be new to *nix. Things like perl in
particular can be security holes waiting to happen if they aren't
properly configured, and thats probably an unwanted burden on a new
sysadmin.
o Perl etc. isn't a part of the 4.4BSD release; now, I'm not saying this
out of religous zeal ("We must go BSD... We must go BSD..." with glazed
over eyes ;-), but one of the huge advantages of NetBSD over, say, Linux
is that the new admin can go out and buy the standard 4.4BSD reference
documents, and more-or-less everything applies. This doesn't prevent
adding on packages like perl really, but its worth bearing in mind before
we go changing the standard shell, mail utility etc...
> David
Just IMHO of course - I can see lots of reasons why it might be a nice
idea too, but personally I'd prefer to be able to easily locate the individual
packages I want to add on, than have them thrown in (that gives me another
reason not to have the kitchen sink included in the standard distrib - hard
disk space). Personally, I'd regard a central packages archive as a
nicer solution. Speaking of which, can anyone point me at a TeX distribution
known to work? :*)
Cheerio, Tim.
--
__ //||/ Tim Walls/TJay EMail tjw1@doc.ic.ac.uk
/_//=|/ Skating away... PGP2.3 Key, finger tjw1@sg1.cc.ic.ac.uk
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
`And with the last line almost drawn, wish you goodbye 'till further on'