Subject: Re: Netatalk: problems with zones >255 under NetBSD 1.3.1
To: Dr. Bill Studenmund <wrstuden@loki.stanford.edu>
From: David Brownlee <abs@anim.dreamworks.com>
List: port-mac68k
Date: 05/09/1998 08:44:59
> > We are seeing a problem where nbplkup (and the mac chooser) on
> > zones with cable ranges >255 fail to pass through the netatalk
> > box.
> >
> Coudl you send me the output of netstat -r?
>
> The NetBSD netatalk code is derived from the FreeBSD code. They recently
> fixed problems in their code, and I've not had a chance to port them to
> NetBSD yet.
It doesn't seem like a routing problem as machines in high numbered
zones can successfully npblkup the contents of low numbered zones
through the netatalk router (filter), just not vica versa.
Included below:
ifconfig -a
netstat -rn
getzones
cat /tmp/atalkd.debug (after sending a USR1 to atalkd)
(filter ~)1# ifconfig -a
de0: flags=8863<UP,BROADCAST,NOTRAILERS,RUNNING,SIMPLEX,MULTICAST> mtu 1500
address: 00:40:05:a0:4e:3d
media: 100baseTX <full-duplex> status: no carrier
inet 192.168.20.5 netmask 0xffffff00 broadcast 192.168.20.255
atalk 202.205 range 202-202 phase 2 broadcast 202.205
de1: flags=8863<UP,BROADCAST,NOTRAILERS,RUNNING,SIMPLEX,MULTICAST> mtu 1500
address: 00:00:92:96:fa:9a
media: 100baseTX <full-duplex> status: no carrier
inet 10.127.3.10 netmask 0xffffff00 broadcast 10.127.3.255
atalk 93.210 range 93-93 phase 2 broadcast 93.210
lo0: flags=8009<UP,LOOPBACK,MULTICAST> mtu 32976
inet 127.0.0.1 netmask 0xff000000
atalk 0.0 range 0-0 phase 2
(filter ~)2# netstat -rn
Routing tables
Internet:
Destination Gateway Flags Refs Use Mtu Interface
default 10.127.3.11 UGS 1 218 - de1
10.127.3/24 link#2 UC 0 0 - de1
10.127.3.11 00:00:a2:c3:3c:ae UHL 1 0 - de1
10.127.3.20 00:00:81:3e:a8:40 UHL 0 1 - de1
10.127.3.255 link#2 UHL 0 1 - de1
127.0.0.1 127.0.0.1 UH 0 0 - lo0
172.16 192.168.20.1 UGS 0 196 - de0
192.168 192.168.20.1 UGS 0 0 - de0
192.168.1 192.168.20.1 UGS 0 1 - de0
192.168.2 192.168.20.1 UGS 0 0 - de0
192.168.3 192.168.20.1 UGS 0 0 - de0
192.168.4 192.168.20.1 UGS 0 1 - de0
192.168.5 192.168.20.1 UGS 0 0 - de0
192.168.6 192.168.20.1 UGS 0 1 - de0
192.168.7 192.168.20.1 UGS 0 3 - de0
192.168.8 192.168.20.1 UGS 0 0 - de0
192.168.11 192.168.20.1 UGS 0 3 - de0
192.168.12 192.168.20.1 UGS 0 0 - de0
192.168.13 192.168.20.1 UGS 0 1 - de0
192.168.17 192.168.20.1 UGS 0 0 - de0
192.168.20 link#1 UC 0 0 - de0
192.168.20.1 00:00:ef:04:12:40 UHL 21 0 - de0
192.168.20.5 00:40:05:a0:4e:3d UHL 1 20 - lo0
192.168.20.255 link#1 UHL 0 1 - de0
192.168.23 192.168.20.1 UGS 0 0 - de0
207.3.193 192.168.20.1 UGS 0 29 - de0
207.3.194 192.168.20.1 UGS 0 13 - de0
207.3.195 192.168.20.1 UGS 0 4 - de0
207.3.197 192.168.20.1 UGS 0 0 - de0
207.3.203 192.168.20.1 UGS 0 0 - de0
207.3.204 192.168.20.1 UGS 0 0 - de0
AppleTalk:
Destination Gateway Flags Refs Use Mtu Interface
0.0 0.0 U 0 2 - lo0
50.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
51.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
52.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
53.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
54.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
55.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
56.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
57.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
58.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
59.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
60.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
61.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
62.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
63.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
64.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
65.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
66.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
67.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
68.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
69.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
70.0 93.44 UG 0 9 - de1
71.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
72.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
73.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
74.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
75.0 93.44 UG 0 2 - de1
76.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
77.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
78.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
79.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
80.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
81.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
82.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
83.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
84.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
85.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
86.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
91.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
92.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
93.0 93.210 U 126 15 - de1
93.210 0.0 UH 0 0 - lo0
98.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
99.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
100.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
101.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
102.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
103.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
104.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
105.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
150.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
151.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
201.0 202.100 UG 0 0 - de0
202.0 202.205 U 18 7 - de0
202.174 0.0 UH 0 0 - lo0
202.205 0.0 UH 1 2 - lo0
210.0 202.100 UG 0 0 - de0
211.0 202.100 UG 0 0 - de0
212.0 202.100 UG 0 2 - de0
213.0 202.100 UG 0 0 - de0
214.0 202.100 UG 0 0 - de0
215.0 202.100 UG 0 0 - de0
216.0 202.100 UG 0 0 - de0
217.0 202.100 UG 0 0 - de0
218.0 202.100 UG 0 0 - de0
219.0 202.100 UG 0 0 - de0
220.0 202.100 UG 0 0 - de0
244.0 202.100 UG 0 0 - de0
245.0 202.100 UG 0 0 - de0
246.0 202.100 UG 0 0 - de0
247.0 202.100 UG 1 1 - de0
301.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
302.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
303.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
304.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
305.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
306.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
996.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
997.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
999.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
1001.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
1002.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
1003.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
1004.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
1005.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
1006.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
1007.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
1008.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
1009.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
4999.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
5000.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
5001.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
9000.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
10001.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
10002.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
30011.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
30012.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
30013.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
30014.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
30015.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
30016.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
30019.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
30021.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
30022.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
30023.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
30024.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
30025.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
30026.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
40001.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
54000.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
54001.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
54002.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
54003.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
54004.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
54005.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
54006.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
54007.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
54008.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
56566.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
64969.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
64970.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
64971.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
64972.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
64977.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
64978.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
64979.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
64980.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
64981.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
64982.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
64984.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
64985.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
64986.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
64987.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
64988.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
64989.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
64990.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
64991.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
64992.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
64993.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
64994.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
64995.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
64996.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
64997.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
64998.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
64999.0 93.44 UG 0 0 - de1
(filter ~)3# getzones
LKS_Anim_DC
Animation
LKS_Anim_Backbone
GLD_Anim_Riverside1
GLD_Anim_Riverside3
GLD_Anim_Camp_1
GLD_Anim_Camp_2
GLD_Anim_Camp_3
GLD_Anim_Riverside2
GLD_Anim_Creative_Services2
GLD_Anim_Feature_1
GLD_Anim_Feature_2
GLD_Anim_Feature_3
GLD_Anim_DC
LKS_Anim_1W
LKS_Anim_1E
LKS_Anim_2W
LKS_Anim_2E
Amblin_Novell
LKS_2
LKS_1
ENC_4
Grandview_1
NYC_1
TOR_1
Montecito1
Interactive
Dreamworks
Rvr_Svr_Frm
Glen_Riverside
Glen_Directors
Glen_Creative_Services
Glen_Feature_Animation
Glen_TV_Animation
Glen_TV_Animationtwo
Glen_TV_Animation_one
Glen_TV_Anim_3
Remote
Zone_ATM
Glen_Wan
Montecito_Wan
NY_1
BelAir_1st
TestLab
TXC_22
TXC_27
TXC_35
TXC_34
(filter ~)4# kill -USR1 721
(filter ~)5# cat /tmp/atalkd.debug
interface lo0 0.0 2AC
0-0 xi
interface de0 202.205 2ACL
202-202 zxi 'LKS_Anim_DC'
gate 202.100 1
201-201 zxi 'LKS_Anim_Backbone'
202-202 x
210-210 zxi 'GLD_Anim_Riverside1'
211-211 zxi 'GLD_Anim_Riverside3'
212-212 zxi 'GLD_Anim_Camp_1'
213-213 zxi 'GLD_Anim_Camp_2'
214-214 zxi 'GLD_Anim_Camp_3'
215-215 zxi 'GLD_Anim_Riverside2'
216-216 zxi 'GLD_Anim_Creative_Services2'
217-217 zxi 'GLD_Anim_Feature_1'
218-218 zxi 'GLD_Anim_Feature_2'
219-219 zxi 'GLD_Anim_Feature_3'
220-220 zxi 'GLD_Anim_DC'
244-244 zxi 'LKS_Anim_1W'
245-245 zxi 'LKS_Anim_1E'
246-246 zxi 'LKS_Anim_2W'
247-247 zxi 'LKS_Anim_2E'
interface de1 93.210 2ACL
93-93 zxi 'Animation'
gate 93.44 2
93-93 x
50-59 zxi 'Amblin_Novell'
60-69 zxi 'Amblin_Novell'
70-80 zxi 'Animation'
81-82 zxi 'LKS_2'
83-84 zxi 'LKS_2'
85-86 zxi 'LKS_2'
91-92 zxi 'LKS_1'
98-99 zxi 'LKS_1'
100-101 zxi 'LKS_1'
102-103 zxi 'LKS_2'
104-105 zxi 'ENC_4'
150-151 zxi 'Grandview_1'
301-302 zxi 'NYC_1'
303-304 zxi 'TOR_1'
305-306 zxi 'Montecito1'
996-996 zi 'Animation'
997-997 zi 'Interactive'
999-999 zi 'Dreamworks'
1001-1001 zxi 'Rvr_Svr_Frm'
1002-1002 zxi 'Glen_Riverside'
1003-1003 zxi 'Glen_Directors'
1004-1004 zxi 'Glen_Creative_Services'
1005-1005 zxi 'Glen_Feature_Animation'
1006-1006 zxi 'Glen_TV_Animation'
1007-1007 zxi 'Glen_TV_Animationtwo'
1008-1008 zxi 'Glen_TV_Animation_one'
1009-1009 zxi 'Glen_TV_Anim_3'
4999-4999 zi 'Remote'
5000-5001 zxi 'Remote'
9000-9000 zxi 'Amblin_Novell'
10001-10001 zxi 'Zone_ATM'
10002-10002 zxi 'Glen_Wan'
30011-30012 zxi 'Dreamworks'
30013-30014 zxi 'Dreamworks'
30015-30016 zxi 'Dreamworks'
30019-30019 zxi 'Amblin_Novell'
30021-30022 zxi 'NYC_1'
30023-30024 zxi 'Montecito_Wan'
30025-30026 zxi 'NY_1'
40001-40001 zxi 'TOR_1'
54000-54000 zxi 'Interactive'
54001-54001 zxi 'Interactive'
54002-54002 zxi 'Interactive'
54003-54003 zxi 'Interactive'
54004-54004 zxi 'Interactive'
54005-54005 zxi 'Interactive'
54006-54006 zxi 'Interactive'
54007-54007 zxi 'Interactive'
54008-54008 zxi 'BelAir_1st'
56566-56566 zi 'Dreamworks'
64969-64969 zxi 'TestLab'
64970-64970 zxi 'TXC_22'
64971-64971 zxi 'TXC_22'
64972-64972 zxi 'TXC_22'
64977-64978 zxi 'TXC_27'
64979-64980 zxi 'TXC_27'
64981-64982 zxi 'TXC_27'
64984-64985 zxi 'Dreamworks'
64986-64987 zxi 'Dreamworks'
64988-64989 zxi 'TXC_35'
64990-64991 zxi 'TXC_35'
64992-64993 zxi 'TXC_35'
64994-64995 zxi 'TXC_34'
64996-64997 zxi 'TXC_34'
64998-64999 zxi 'TXC_34'
(filter ~)6# exit