Re: pthread-mutex debugging (PR#44387)

[Michael <macallan%netbsd.org@localhost>]

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

Hello,

On Sep 22, 2012, at 3:20 PM, Frank Wille wrote:

> today I spent some time on debugging PR #44387 (some pthread mutex  
> tests
> run forever). As Jeff Rizzo wrote, the problem disappears when  
> compiling
> a kernel with DIAGNOSTIC option.
>
> I could now isolate the problem on sys/kern/kern_mutex.c. It was
> sufficient to compile kern_mutex.c with -DFULL to make the problem
> disappear. The rest of the kernel was compiled without DIAGNOSTIC.
>
> FULL enables the use of __cpu_simple_lock_try() and  
> __cpu_simple_unlock()
> when locking/unlocking a mutex, which sets/unsets a variable in an
> atomic operation.
>
> Unfortunately I still don't see what is wrong here. I fear the problem
> is somewhere else and using the "full" locking code hides it somehow.

Hmm, I wonder if this is somehow related to the SMP problems we still  
have on macppc ( I didn't try just DIAGNOSTIC in a long time though,  
so I don't know if that helps. I'll try next chance I get. A while ago  
I had to run with LOCKDEBUG in order to get it halfway stable. ) -  
lots of filesystem activity gets processes stuck in all sorts of funny  
ways ( which I don't see on sparc64 or amd64 SMP ), not necessarily in  
anything filesystem related and it can take anything between 5 minutes  
and a whole build.sh distribution to show up. I long suspected that  
there's something wrong with locking primitives or related code but  
couldn't prove it or figure out what exactly goes wrong.
Running with just one CPU online makes the problems go away.

have fun
Michael

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.7 (Darwin)
Comment: GPGTools - http://gpgtools.org

iQEVAwUBUF5kBMpnzkX8Yg2nAQKC0wgAn1J+Xec7o2+zf/IbCRXM8IRz20uBOpmx
U013Qdbwq0m1m8EFn6A4Sj0KzcMuKXvZ4J+yj99Xe3lQDdl+ggLpNnpLKqAl11A8
6L29jDYjcikhyM+nYMBnFxpawuT46kU29mBozALhClB7VLkmh77hbU7Y+3sHWlia
CNTerdndhxYOZPjWNrzcGJ+ywL9oyncZyJwS0oenPwFmgItAh8Po93wq5JowFnRe
YhVS34G04HsgQ+Gl4MsQoPlWGlqjptN5nyYBBFN+3FPjcKIOsIruSRinj+cD/Atm
ml7CYQo/qmM7MNXZJExqv3YA46CQoVhKOhF5gDQOLnDosGvVS4f0Hw==
=VME1
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----