IETF-SSH archive

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index][Old Index]

Re: Case sensitivity on sftp servers



Though I agree that specifying case sensitivity may be useful, I think that
specifying it on a server wide basis is too broad.

The server may offer several file systems and some of these may not preserve
case, while others may preserve case but not be case sensitive, and still
other may preserve case and be case sensitive.

The server may also have the option of allowing the client to specify
whether or not file operations are case sensitive on a file system that
preserves case.

It may be necessary to specify a method of obtaining the file systems
available and their characteristics (Read Only, Case Preserving, Case
Sensitive, etc.)

You raise a good point--- hmmm... let's try this on
for size:

new attrib bit:

SSH_FILEXFER_ATTR_FILESYSTEM
	string filesystem-name

SSH_FILEXFER_ATTR_FILESYSTEM is only sent by the server
if the client requested it by including in the flags
mask during readdir or stat operation and the file
in question is a directory.

filesystem-name is a handle that can be passed back
to the server using the "read-filesystem-attributes"
It need not be human readable.

--
byte   SSH_FXP_EXTENDED
uint32 request-id
string "read-filesystem-attributes"
string filesystem-name

byte SSH_FXP_EXTENDED_REPLY
uint32 request-id
uint32 file-system attribute flags
	CASE_SENSITIVE
	CASE_PRESERVITIVE
	CASE_OPTIONAL
string-utf8 invalid-chars
uint32 reserved-name-count
string reserved-name[1..reserved-name-count]

And, a new flag bit in in the modes during open to
specify that the filename should be case sensitive
or case insensitive.  If the server can't comply,
it return OP_UNSUPPORTED.

What do you think?

I think I keep the "default-file-attributes" and then
the filesystem only need be sent if it is different from
the default.

- Joseph




Home | Main Index | Thread Index | Old Index